Shrewsbury is a historic town in southern York County, just minutes from the Maryland border. Conveniently located along I-83, residents enjoy easy access to York, Harrisburg, and Baltimore, all while appreciating the relaxed pace of small-town living. The area offers local shops, dining, parks, and scenic countryside views, creating an ideal setting to call home.
Keystone Custom Homes is proud to offer new homes for sale in Shrewsbury, PA. Discover a home you can personalize to fit your lifestyle, with thoughtfully designed floorplans and a wide range of design choices.
For over 30 years, Keystone Custom Homes has worked with families to design and build homes that reflect their unique needs and style. We believe homebuilding should be a collaborative process focused on your goals, your vision, and your family’s future.
From selecting the perfect floorplan to your final walkthrough, our team provides expert guidance, transparent communication, and support throughout every step of the journey.
When you choose Keystone as your homebuilder in Shrewsbury, you’re partnering with a trusted name known for craftsmanship, innovation, and personalization.
Your New Home Advisor will help you explore available communities, homesites, and floorplans to find the perfect combination for your lifestyle.
Visit one of our Design Studios to personalize your home’s interior and exterior finishes. With over 1,500 Value-Added Features, including cabinetry, flooring, lighting, and more, you’ll have endless options to make your home uniquely yours.
You can also tour our Model Homes to gain inspiration and see how our thoughtful designs blend function, comfort, and style.
As an award-winning custom homebuilder in Shrewsbury, Keystone Custom Homes is dedicated to building energy-efficient, comfortable, and long-lasting homes. Every home includes premium insulation, Low-E windows, energy-efficient appliances, and advanced HVAC systems to enhance comfort and reduce energy costs.
Each Keystone home is backed by a 20-year structural warranty, giving you confidence in the quality and durability of your investment.
Once you’ve chosen your homesite in or around Shrewsbury, your New Home Advisor will walk you through floorplan options and design possibilities. After finalizing your home design and completing your purchase agreement, structural changes can be made before construction begins.
You’ll then meet with a Designer at our Lancaster, PA, Design Studio to choose finishes that reflect your personal style.
During construction, your Construction Manager will provide progress updates through our MyKCH app, keeping you informed and involved as your dream home takes shape.
Keystone Custom Homes is proud to be ranked among Builder Magazine’s Top 100 Homebuilders and recognized as America’s Best Builder three times. Our reputation for excellence is built on integrity, craftsmanship, and customer satisfaction.
Whether you’re looking for a Quick Move-In Home or wish to build On Your Lot, our team is ready to help you create your ideal home in Shrewsbury, PA.
Call us at 717-368-9831 or connect with an Online Advisor today to learn more about building with Keystone Custom Homes in Shrewsbury!
Welcome to your MyKeystone account! Save your favorites, get personalized recommendations, and more!
No, I Want to Keep Viewing Homes